Under Australian patent law, there is no statutory position on whether a business method is
patentable subject matter, and so it is legal precedent that provides guidance.

The watershed NRDC (1) case opened the door to what can be considered patentable subject matter in Australian law, to beyond merely ‘vendible products’ (2) , and now includes things such as living organisms, genetic materials, computer software and methods of treating humans.

Those principles were applied in the 2006 case of Grant v Commissioner of Patents (3) which involved a method for restructuring financial trusts to the benefit of members. In denying the patent, the Full Court said that the patent must results in some kind of physical phenomenon or transformation in order to be patentable. In this instance, as there was no physical effect or application, the patent was not allowed. The case is relevant in that it qualifies the broad NRDC by requiring some physical effect to be brought about by the patent.

The policy of IP Australia is to treat business methods like any other subject matter, in that they are
not specifically excluded so long as they meet all the other requirements of patent law. (4) Thus, the
current position of business methods as patentable subject matter in Australia is that a business
methods may be patentable long as it has some physical phenomenon or manifestation. IP
Australia makes the following statement:

“A patent may be granted for a business method where the method directly involves a physical form
or device to bring about a useful product. The application of technology for conducting a business
method must be directly involved in a substantial way, not an incidental way.” See here for more.

In regards to the legislature making a statement on this rather than the judiciary, a 2003 review (5) by Australia’s Advisory Council on Intellectual Property of the appropriateness of patenting business
methods which found it may not be desirable said the issue was not significant enough to warrant a
change to Australian patent law. So a legislative statement any time soon look unlikely.

In any case, patents are both very difficult and very expensive to obtain. You may have other
intellectual property rights in your business that you can identify. A trademark is a different (not
alternative) form of intellectual property protection for your business. A trademark will protect your
name or brand which in many cases is more important than any business method underlying the
function of the business.

 

 

1 National Research Development Corp v Commissioner of Patents (1959) 102 CLR 252; 1A IPR 63 at CLR 275;
IPR 74 (High Court of Australia)
2 As ruled under Morton’s Rules.
3 Grant v Commissioner of Patents [2006] FCAFC 120
4 See para 2.9.2.10 of the IP Australia Patent Examiner’s Manual
5 Australia’s Advisory Council on Intellectual Property, Report on a Review of the Patenting of Business Systems,
September 2003

Need some advice on this?

If you need some more advice in your particualr case, we offer a free initial consultation.

When Do I Need to Trademark?

As a new business manager, you might ask yourself whether it is necessary to register your trademark immediately or if it is something that can wait until you are more established in the marketplace. You might wonder why, if you have already taken the steps to...

Trademark attorneys and trademark lawyers in Australia

I often get asked about the difference in Australia between a trade mark attorney and a trade mark lawyer.  In Australia, a trade mark attorney is a separate profession to that of a lawyer or a ‘trade mark lawyer’. While both professions are legal entitled to work in...

Can I Trademark My Instagram or Facebook Account?

Is it possible to trademark an Instagram or Facebook account? The short answer is, yes, you can. Like any other name or logo, Instagram and Facebook accounts accrue good will and reputation that businesses wish to protect. And they can be legally protected by a...

Protect your trade mark in the United States

There is no single worldwide trade mark registration.  You will need to apply to each country in which you would like to have a registered trade mark.  Even for large companies, this task can prove too cumbersome and expensive.  Therefore, the pragmatic route is to...

Differences between IRDA and national trade marks

Are there any substantive differences in trade marks practice and law between trade marks protected in Australia as international marks and national marks?   INTRODUCTION International trade marks and brands that exist and trade in nations across the globe are...

When Do I Need to Trademark?

As a new business manager, you might ask yourself whether it is necessary to register your trademark immediately or if it is something that can wait until you are more established in the marketplace. You might wonder why, if you have already taken the steps to...

Problems with Amazon Recognising IP Australia Trademarks

To protect its seller's trademarks, Amazon has recently rolled out its Amazon Brand Registry to Australian sellers.  To learn more about what the Amazon Brand Registry is for trademarks and why you should use it to protect your brand, you can read our recent article...

Difference Between Trademarks, Copyright and Patents

There is often confusion about the differences between trademarks, patents and copyright.  This is no surprise as the law in this area is quite complex and very conceptual.  This post provides a brief overview of the differences. But firstly, let’s start with the...

What Happens If I Don’t Get a Trademark?

Do I Need a Registered Trademark? Having an officially registered trademark for your business is not actually a legal requirement.  As long as you are otherwise obeying the legal obligations of running your business, such as having the correct licences, paying taxes...

Trade mark an invention or product

A trade mark can be a strong mechanism of protection for an invention or a product. This can be especially useful in cases where patent protection is not possible or otherwise difficult. A product can be branded with a name or logo. Even the shape of a product can be...